Market Survey: Despite Difficulty, First-Time Buyers Persist in the 2023 Market

Lack of Repeat Buyers Opens Window for First-Time Home Shoppers.

July 18,  2023

Erica Plemmons

Elevated interest rates have been a key factor in the 2023 housing market, making sellers hesitant to list. As a result, the Mid-Atlantic continues to struggle with low inventory, one of the many common sentiments shared by agents and brokers in Bright’s latest subscriber survey. Buyers must contend with affordability and a dearth of supply, but with challenge comes opportunity. 

Here are the key findings from the July 2023 survey of Bright MLS subscribers:  

First-Time Buyers a Surprisingly High Share of the Market 

Marking a strong shift from the past several years, 2023 may be the year of the first-time buyer. The National Association of REALTORS® reported the portion of first-time buyers shrank to 26% in 2022, down from 34% in 2021, and its smallest share on record. 

Nearly half (48%) of buyer agents indicated they worked with a first-time buyer on sales that closed in June. Bright’s subscriber survey has found that since March, at least 40% of Mid-Atlantic buyers each month have been first-time buyers. 

As interest rates climbed in the latter half of last year and stayed elevated through mid-2023, most buyers considering a move are doing so out of necessity (e.g., marriage, divorce, job change). Repeat buyers clinging to a low mortgage rate are disincentivized, leaving room for persistent first-time buyers to get an opportunity at homeownership. 

Multiple Offers Typical, Not As Many As Last Year 

Buyers must prepare for a competitive environment. Multiple offers continue to be the norm as nearly three out of four seller’s agents (73.9%) report they received at least two offers on the listing. One respondent shared, “[I]f [it is a] very nice updated home, [there will be] multiple offers but not going quite as high as last year.” 

Bright’s subscriber survey started in March 2023 so there isn’t a figure for last year available. Yet from comments like these from agents and brokers, it is clear that while multiple offers remain common, the market has cooled from the hyper-frenzied pace of 2021 and 2022. 

Although competition has eased from a year ago, the market has heated up through the spring and beginning of summer. In February, the average number of offers a seller received was 2.7 and in June it was 3.5. Last month nearly one-third of sellers (31.7%) received four or more offers.  

From the buyer’s perspective, the majority aren’t successful on their first attempt. In the July survey, more than two-thirds of buyers had to submit an offer on more than one property before they were successful.  

A Tale of Two Markets 

While competition remains tight, each listing is individual. Many agents are reporting that there seems to be two different markets: one similar though not as frenetic as last year and another much slower market. 

As one subscriber stated, “Some houses sell quickly with multiple offers while other homes sit and linger with price reductions.” 

One thing everyone agrees on–this market is constrained by low inventory. Active listings dropped for the first time in 13 consecutive months in the Mid-Atlantic. 

Low Inventory Challenges Buyers 

Limited inventory available is the biggest challenge for buyers. For buyers who closed on a home in June, 43% of agents said that finding the right home was very difficult (14%) or somewhat difficult (29%). 

Following finding the right home, the next difficulty buyers faced was submitting a successful offer (14% very difficult and 13% somewhat difficult); recall that only 31.2% won on their first offer. Demand continues to outpace supply so these obstacles will remain in the foreseeable future. 

Sellers who aren’t looking to purchase another home are having an easier time in today’s market than sellers who need to sell and also buy a home. The biggest challenge for sellers not purchasing another home was pricing, though only 15.5% of agents responded that these sellers found that process somewhat or very difficult. However, sellers who were also purchasing a home indicated finding another home to buy was their biggest struggle, with two out of five sellers (40.8%) classifying it as somewhat or very difficult. 

Outlook  

While spring was less robust than in years past, transactions increased from the winter months and agents and brokers were optimistic about market activity in the summer. Sentiment among brokers and agents has consistently declined since April. For the buyer outlook, in July only 38.9% of agents and brokers expect high to very high activity in the coming three months compared to over half (50.5%) in April. Part of the decline could be seasonal, as real estate professionals tend to expect slower conditions in the fall. 

Similarly, there’s less optimism for sellers who are holding onto low rates and are also struggling to find a new home because of the lack of inventory. In April, roughly half (50.7%) predicted seller activity would be low to very low three months out, and in July that figure has bumped up to 60.6%. 

Agents and brokers are hoping for an ease in interest rates to motivate sellers to list, but many respondents are anticipating a more challenging second half of 2023. And while the near-term may be tough, some are looking ahead to a brighter market in 2024. 

About Bright

Bright is proud to be the source of truth for comprehensive real estate data in the Mid-Atlantic, with market intelligence currently covering six states (Delaware, Maryland, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Virginia, West Virginia) and the District of Columbia. Bright MLS’s innovative tool library—both created and curated—provides services and award-winning support to well over 100k real estate professionals, enabling their delivery on the promise of home to over half a million homebuyers and sellers monthly. In 2022, Bright subscribers facilitated $121B in real estate transactions through the company’s platform.

A total of 771 agents representing recent homebuyers and 876 agents representing recent home sellers responded to Bright MLS’s survey. The survey was conducted between July 6 and July 11, 2023. Full survey results are available here. More research and analysis on the housing market is available from Bright MLS’s Research Team.

Exclusive Market Research & Analysis

For regular updates on the housing market, including weekly insights from Dr. Lisa, please visit BrightMLS.com/Research.

Recent articles

Back to Top