NEWS
Market Survey: Is Conventional Wisdom About the Housing Market Wrong?
Results from Bright MLS’s survey indicate a Mid-Atlantic housing market that defies expectations.
The spring housing market is one of paradoxes. On the one hand, market activity is slow this spring, with home sales and new listings below pre-pandemic levels. On the other hand, home shoppers are still finding the market competitive, as inventory is still low and homes are selling quickly. Reports from Bright MLS subscribers, who are working every day with buyers and sellers, provide valuable insights into what is really going on in the market—and may upend some commonly held beliefs about how to think about buyer and seller behavior.
Key findings from the April 2023 survey of Bright MLS subscribers:
Investors and owners of rental properties are big sources of new listings coming onto the market. New listing activity has been at a two-decade low, primarily because homeowners with rock-bottom mortgage rates are not enticed to sell and give up that favorable rate. But people do need to move. According to Bright MLS’s survey, the most common reason recent sellers put their home on the market was for family reasons, including marriage, divorce, or to move to be closer to family.
Very close behind were individuals who were selling a rental or investment property—about one out of every six sales in March was a rental or investment property. Delaware had the greatest share of sales of investment or rental properties, accounting for 21.4% of March sales. Maryland came in second at 19.1%. This pattern suggests that people who purchased second homes or investment homes during the pandemic—particularly in coastal markets—might be looking to offload them as we head into the summer months.
More investment properties, rental properties, or second homes coming onto the market could change the inventory outlook in some markets. Owners of these properties are not impacted by “rate lock” in the same way that owners of primary residences are.
Despite concerns about elevated mortgage rates, most buyer and seller decisions are not being driven by rates. Mortgage rates topped 7% back in the fall and have been up and down during the first quarter of 2023. There has been speculation that recent rate volatility has accelerated decisions to buy or sell a home, but that does not appear to be the case in the Mid-Atlantic region.
According to Bright MLS subscribers, nearly nine out of 10 sellers (87.2%) indicated that mortgage rates did not influence their decision to sell. Only 1.1% were selling now because they believed mortgage rates were going to move higher.
Mortgage rates were a bigger factor for buyers, but the majority claimed that rates were not a factor in the decision to buy. One reason rates were not a major issue was because so many buyers in the Mid-Atlantic are not financing their home purchase. About one in five recent buyers (20.1%) bought with cash. Nearly half of recent homebuyers (49.6%) were going to buy regardless of mortgage rates.
About a quarter of homebuyers (23.9%) were taking mortgage rates into consideration when they made the decision to buy, but for most of them, rates were just one factor—and not the main factor—in their decision to buy.
While the presumption is that buyers are very rate sensitive, particularly in a rising-rate environment, the link between mortgage rates and purchasing decisions may not be so clear cut. The ability to pay cash for a home discounts the importance of where rates stand. In addition, buyers who are able to roll equity from another home into their purchase will also be less concerned about rates. According to the survey results, repeat buyers are much less likely than first-time buyers to indicate mortgage rates were a factor in their buying decision—17.4% versus 31.4%. Therefore, if mortgage rates do stay elevated or even rise further in 2023, there may be less of an impact on demand than might be commonly expected.
First-time homebuyers are finding opportunities in the Mid-Atlantic, but they are dealing with a very competitive market. The National Association of REALTORS® reported just 26% of home purchases in 2022 were made by first-time buyers, the lowest share since NAR has been tracking data. In the Mid-Atlantic housing market, however, nearly half of all recent homebuyers were first-time buyers, suggesting that the Mid-Atlantic market could afford more opportunities than some other parts of the country.
Not surprisingly, first-time buyers are more likely to buy smaller, less expensive homes. In the Mid-Atlantic market, the median price of a home purchased by a recent first-time buyer was $360,000, while the median price for a repeat buyer was $400,000. Repeat buyers are more likely to purchase single-family detached homes while first-time buyers are much more likely to purchase townhomes and condos.
It is clear, however, that first-time buyers in the Mid-Atlantic face a more competitive market than do repeat buyers. More than four out of 10 first-time buyers (43.5%) paid over list price for their home, compared to 35.9% of repeat buyers. First-time buyers had to make offers on an average of 2.8 homes before they had an offer accepted, compared to an average of 2.2 offers made by repeat buyers. First-time buyers are losing out, no matter what price point they are buying at. The most competitive segment of the market is homes priced between $300,000 and $499,999 for which first-time buyers made offers on an average of three homes before successfully closing.
A big reason first-time buyers face more challenging conditions is that they are competing against repeat buyers who are bringing cash—sometimes significant cash—to the deal. More than one-third of repeat buyers paid cash for the home they bought in March, compared with just 4% of first-time buyers.
Consensus about the spring market—buyers will be interested, but sellers will be few. According to the Bright MLS subscribers who responded to this month’s survey, there is general consensus that buyer activity will be much stronger than seller activity over the next three months. In fact, the outlooks for buyer and seller activity are nearly mirror images of each other.
More than 50% of survey respondents indicated that buyer activity would be “high to very high” in the next three months. A virtual identical share of respondents said that seller activity would be “low or very low.”
The real estate professionals that responded to this survey are those that were involved in a real estate transaction—either on the buy side or the sell side—in March and are therefore very attuned to what is going on in the market. Their perceptions of active buyer demand and limited seller interest will likely characterize the rest of the spring market.
Bright is proud to be the source of truth for comprehensive real estate data in the Mid-Atlantic, with market intelligence currently covering six states (Delaware, Maryland, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Virginia, West Virginia) and the District of Columbia. Bright MLS’s innovative tool library—both created and curated—provides services and award-winning support to well over 100k real estate professionals, enabling their delivery on the promise of home to over half a million homebuyers and sellers monthly. In 2022, Bright subscribers facilitated $121B in real estate transactions through the company’s platform.
A total of 754 agents representing recent homebuyers and 1,222 agents representing recent home sellers responded to Bright MLS’s survey. The survey was conducted between April 6 and April 11, 2023. Full survey results are available here. More research and analysis on the housing market is available from Bright MLS’s Research Team.
Exclusive Market Research & Analysis
For regular updates on the housing market, including weekly insights from Dr. Lisa, please visit BrightMLS.com/Research.