Market Survey: Is It Finally a Buyer’s Market?

More inventory, lower rates make it easier to be a buyer in 2025.

April 30,  2025

Lisa Sturtevant, PhD

In recent years, it has been very much a seller’s market. However, results from Bright MLS surveys of real estate agents working with buyers and sellers in the first quarter of 2025 suggest that the outlook for buyers is improving. Buyers have more listings to choose from and face less competition in the market. Fewer would-be buyers are leaving the market frustrated by losing out on homes. The 2025 housing market is definitely feeling different to buyers, according to insights from Bright MLS agents.

While the seller’s market run may be coming to an end, it’s too soon to say whether or how far the pendulum will shift to buyers. What is clear is that homebuyers in the Bright MLS service area are facing fewer obstacles to buying than they did a year ago. Whether this continues to be the case depends not only on housing market conditions, but also on broader trends in the overall economy.

Buyers are benefiting from more inventory

Homebuyers were able to move quickly at the beginning of 2025. Nearly 40% of buyers who closed on a home in the first quarter of 2025 had been looking for less than a month. This is a significantly higher share than in 2024, when less than 20% of successful buyers looked for a home for less than a month.

Share of Buyers Who Were Looking for a Home for Less than a Month

More supply is one important reason why buyers found a home more quickly. After years of very limited inventory, an increase in new listings offered buyers more options to start 2025. This marks a notable change from the past few years, when buyers were competing over a dearth of inventory and typically had to make offers on multiple homes before they reached the settlement table.

In the first quarter of 2025, more buyers only had to make an offer on one home. About 50% of buyers who closed in the first quarter of 2025 had made an offer on just the home they ultimately purchased. This is a slightly higher share than we have seen in recent months and suggests that buyers are starting to have an easier time in this less competitive market.

First-time buyers still face more competition than repeat buyers. In the first quarter of 2025, about 43% of first-time buyers were successful with one offer, compared to more than half (51%) of repeat buyers.

Buyers are still compromising

Moving quickly does not necessarily mean buyers are finding the exact home they want.  According to our agent survey, about 45% of all buyers who closed on a home in the first quarter of 2025 said that they had to make some type of compromise as they searched for a home. This is up slightly from the second half of 2024. Because the market has been so competitive for so long, even when buyers have more listings to choose from, they know that they still need to be flexible.

The most common trade-off was around location, with nearly one-third of agents saying buyers who compromised did so on location (e.g. neighborhood, school district). Other big compromises were on quality of the home (27.6%) and price (26.0%).

Because buyers are compromising on home quality or are purchasing a home “as is,” it is possible that they are still feeling pressure and are worried that they could miss out. While sellers may be more likely to negotiate as we head into the spring market, in the first quarter of 2025, according to Bright MLS agents, they were less likely to offer closing cost assistance or credit for repairs than they were in 2024.

Mortgage rates don’t have to come down too much to entice buyers

Mortgage rates hovered around 7% to start the year, but rates have come down a little over the past few months. Even a modest drop in rates made a difference to homebuyers. In the first quarter of 2025, more than 80% of agents said their homebuyer found it “very easy” or “somewhat easy” to qualify for a mortgage.

Furthermore, fewer home shoppers have paused their home search because of high mortgage rates. According to our survey of agents, about 69% had been working with a client who stopped looking. Last year, high mortgage rates were the primary reason prospective homebuyers sat out the market, but mortgage rates are less of an obstacle to buyers. In the first quarter of 2025, agents reported that about 42% of their clients who had stopped looking did so because of high mortgage rates. That share is down from close to 60% in 2024.

High Mortgage Rates the Reason Would-Be Buyers Stop Looking

The results from first quarter 2025 survey data suggest that mortgage rates do not necessarily need to fall significantly to bring buyers into the market. Rather, if rates continue on a general downward trend, that could be enough, along with more inventory, to entice more buyers into the market this spring.

Agents see more opportunities for buyers in the months ahead

According to Bright’s Seller Activity Index, which is a measure of agents’ outlook for how active sellers will be in the next three months, we should expect more listings this spring than there were last spring. The Seller Activity Index of 47.2 in April is about the same as it was in March but is up significantly from a year ago (35.4).

Agents are optimistic that buyers will also be active in the coming months, though the outlook is more cautious than it was a year ago. The Buyer Activity Index was 60.1, which was still optimistic. (An Index value above 50 indicates optimism in future market activity.) However, the Buyer Index is much lower than it was last April when it was at a near record high of 68.1.

Bright MLS Buyer and Seller Activity Indices

About the survey

Bright MLS conducts monthly surveys of agents who are actively working with buyers and sellers. Each month, a total of about 1,000 agents respond to the survey, including about 500 agents representing buyers and 500 agents representing sellers. Full study results and more research and analysis on the housing market are available from Bright Research.

Exclusive Market Research & Analysis

Get the latest research and studies from Bright at BrightMLS.com/Research.

Recent articles

Back to Top