Results from Bright MLS’s latest survey indicate that the share of first-time buyers is holding steady despite challenges.
NEWS
Market Survey: More Listings Hitting the Market
Results from Bright MLS’s latest survey reveal that some sellers are not in the market to buy.
Not All Sellers Are Buyers
When people sell a home, they often are looking to buy another one, so an increase in new listings also means an increase in new buyers. These repeat buyers bring equity to their offers, which has frustrated first-time homebuyers in this competitive market. But the inventory picture is improving and results from Bright MLS’s most recent survey show that nearly two out of five listings were from a seller who was probably not turning around and buying another home.
According to agents surveyed, 61.9% of homes sold in March were primary residences, suggesting a seller who might be in the market to also buy. However, other listings added to the inventory that were not primary residences. For example, 14.3% of homes sold in March were rental properties. Another 13.5% were estate sales, or the sale of a property whose owner had passed away. Second homes, vacation homes, investment properties, builder sales, and foreclosures and short sales were also part of the inventory of sellers who probably were not also buyers.
Our survey also revealed that even some people selling a primary residence are not buying another home. A seller could move into the home of a new spouse or family member, become a renter, or move into a second home or vacation property. According to survey data for the first quarter of 2024, 47.5% of agents who worked with a seller listing their primary residence indicated that their seller was not in the market to purchase another home. People selling for health reasons were typically not buying—nearly eight out of 10 were not in the market to purchase another home. These may be individuals moving into assisted living or nursing facilities.
More Inventory Hasn’t Shifted the Balance to Buyers
An increase in sellers who are not buyers has helped the inventory situation, albeit slightly. Active listings were 3.9% higher across the Mid-Atlantic at the end of March 2024 than a year prior. Buyers welcome having more choices. According to our survey of agents on the ground, fewer home shoppers are stopping or pausing their home search. In April, about 70% of survey respondents said they had worked with a buyer who had stopped or paused their home search in the past six months, compared to 76% at the beginning of the year.
Mortgage rates remain a pain point for buyers. In April, 62.5% of buyer agents who had a client pause or stop their home search attributed the decision to mortgage rates being too high. With the Federal Reserve delaying rate cuts until later in the year, those deterred by mortgage rates will continue to stay on the sidelines.
Outlook for Buyer and Seller Activity
The Bright MLS buyer activity outlook has turned downward in the face of growing affordability challenges. (The Bright market activity indices compare agents and brokers who selected a “high to very high” outlook to those selecting “low to very low” to gauge market sentiment. An index above 50 indicates optimism about buyer/seller activity.) The buyer activity index was 68.1 in April, which suggests a positive outlook for buyer activity; however, the index has dropped over six points from the high of 74.2 in March. Further, the outlook is lower than a year ago when the index was 70.4.
On the other hand, the outlook for seller activity ticked up slightly from 35.1 in March to 35.4 in April. While the index still suggests pessimism around seller activity, the measure has improved from last year at this time. Though there has been a shift in expectations for buyer and seller participation, it’s clear that demand is still outweighing supply.
What’s Changed (or Hasn’t) in the Past Year?
Bright MLS has been conducting a monthly survey of brokers and agents for more than a year, which now allows us to compare current conditions with those of last year. Some market characteristics have remained similar to last year. On average, sellers received 3.4 offers, matching the average in March 2023. Buyers are still likely to have to make more than one offer to be successful.
The top reason for buying continues to be the desire to become a first-time homebuyer or those tired of renting. This reason has topped the list every month in the past year. The competition is tough whether the buyer is a first-timer or repeat. While first-timers tend to have more difficulty with submitting a successful offer, both first-time and repeat buyers experience the same struggle to find the right home in today’s restricted inventory environment.
In March 2024, 18.7% of buyers purchased a home within one month of searching, similar to the share a year ago (19.2%). The share who had to search for six months or more was also similar (24.0% in March 2024 compared to 23.3% in March 2023).
About Bright
Bright is proud to be the source of truth for comprehensive real estate data in the Mid-Atlantic, with market intelligence currently covering six states (Delaware, Maryland, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Virginia, West Virginia) and the District of Columbia. Bright MLS’s innovative tool library—both created and curated—provides services and award-winning support to well over 100k real estate professionals, enabling their delivery on the promise of home to over half a million homebuyers and sellers monthly. In 2023, Bright subscribers facilitated $104B in real estate transactions through the company’s platform.
A total of 491 agents representing recent homebuyers and 533 agents representing recent home sellers responded to Bright MLS’s survey. The survey was conducted between April 4 and April 11, 2024. Full survey results are available here. More research and analysis on the housing market is available from Bright MLS’s Research Team.
Exclusive Market Research & Analysis
Get the latest research and studies from Bright at BrightMLS.com/Research.
Recent articles
Results from Bright MLS’s latest survey reveal that a lack of inventory is the main reason buyers and sellers are staying on the sidelines.