Market Survey: More than Half of Sellers in the Mid-Atlantic Are Not Buyers

With more inventory in the market, agents expect this fall to be busier than last year according to Bright MLS’s latest survey.

October 17,  2024

Erica Plemmons

There are more new listings coming onto the market as we head into the fall. An increase in the number of sellers traditionally has meant more buyers in the market, as well, with prior research showing that about two-thirds of people selling a home are also buying. However, according to Bright MLS’ latest survey, that share may be overstated.

About three out of five homes that sold in September in the Bright MLS service area were the seller’s primary residence. According to the agents representing those sellers, just under half of those sellers did not purchase another home.

Based on survey responses from agents, some of this is a timing issue, and these home sellers will eventually buy. Examples include a seller moving to a new state who wanted to understand the area before they purchased a home, and a divorced couple getting their bearings before deciding where to live.

But there are other sellers who are not planning to purchase another home at all. These include homeowners selling their primary residence with plans to move into a second home; those merging households, such as newly married couples; and individuals moving to assisted living facilities or nursing homes.

In addition to these primary residences being sold, other types of listings coming onto the market will add to the inventory without bringing in a new buyer. In September, nearly two in five (37.6%) homes that sold were not the seller’s primary residences. These listings, including second and vacation homes, investment properties, and estate sales, are an important part of the increasing inventory in the Mid-Atlantic market.
 

More Than Half of Sellers Are Not Buyers, Helping to Grow Inventory
 

More Inventory Will Bring Even More Sellers into the Market

According to the latest survey, about a third of agents have worked with a homeowner who decided not to sell, a share that has been fairly consistent since June. Ironically, a lack of inventory is keeping more sellers from listing their home. The primary reason potential sellers are holding back is because they could not find another home to buy.
 

Inventory Can Hold Back Prospective Sellers From Listing
 

As the market loosens with more inventory, additional sellers will be incentivized to list their homes because they can find another to buy. Falling mortgage rates could be the factor that sways the financial equation for some homeowners, encouraging them to reconsider whether listing their home is the right decision.

Agents Expect Stronger Close to 2024

Listing activity is on the rise, and the agents and brokers surveyed expect the fourth quarter to fare better in 2024. Both the Bright MLS Buyers’ and Sellers’ indices were higher in October than they were a year ago.

The indices compare the number of agents and brokers who anticipate high to very high activity to the number expecting low to very low activity in order to gauge sentiment. A reading above 50 is generally optimistic, while a reading below 50 is more pessimistic. The October buyer index of 53.8 indicates that agents and brokers are still optimistic despite a typical seasonal drop of 1.3 points from September. Compared to a year ago, the outlook for buyer activity is much stronger, with the index being over 13 points higher than last year at this time.
 

Outlook for Q4 Better Than Last Year
 

Similarly, the seller index also dipped from September but remains higher than it was in 2023. The index fell 2.2 points from a month ago but remains nearly 20 points higher than October 2023.

The month-over-month dip in the buyers’ and sellers’ indices reflects agents’ and brokers’ expectations of a typical seasonal slowdown in the housing market. But market conditions are much stronger than they were a year ago.

About Bright

Bright is proud to be the source of truth for comprehensive real estate data in the Mid-Atlantic, with market intelligence currently covering six states (Delaware, Maryland, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Virginia, West Virginia) and the District of Columbia. Bright MLS’s innovative tool library—both created and curated—provides services and award-winning support to well over 100k real estate professionals, enabling their delivery on the promise of home to over half a million homebuyers and sellers monthly. In 2023, Bright subscribers facilitated $104B in real estate transactions through the company’s platform.

A total of 529 agents representing recent homebuyers and 601 agents representing recent home sellers responded to Bright MLS’s survey. The survey was conducted between October 4 and October 11, 2024. Full survey results are available here. More research and analysis on the housing market is available from Bright Research.

Exclusive Market Research & Analysis

Get the latest research and studies from Bright at BrightMLS.com/Research.

Recent articles

Back to Top