Lack of Repeat Buyers Opens Window for First-Time Home Shoppers.
NEWS
Market Survey: Demand Persists and Sellers Resist
Results from Bright MLS’s survey indicate that education and cooperation are essential for a smooth transaction process.
Buyers Press on with Limited Mid-Atlantic Homes
“Demand from buyers outweighs the number of homes on the market” one agent remarked in the latest subscriber survey focusing on July 2023 transactions. According to Bright’s July monthly market statistics, inventory woes are not improving, with the number of active listings down 19.1% year-over-year across the Mid-Atlantic.
Buyers continue to be surprisingly persistent, despite elevated prices and interest rates hindering affordability. Yet buyers aren’t willing to accept any home on the market. Listing agents indicate buyers desire move-in ready properties. Some buyers in the market are moving out of necessity while others are taking the plunge even when buying is more discretionary.
Why Buyers Persist in Today’s Market?
The most common reason for purchasing a home, according to agents working with buyers who closed on a home in July, was simply the desire for homeownership. Over one-third (34.4%) of buyers’ agents indicated the primary reason their client pursued a purchase was to become a homeowner for the first time or they were simply tired of renting (though they could have previously owned a home). Note that while 41% of July buyer agents worked with first-time buyers, occasionally their main motivation to move was jobs, larger space or moving for family.
Both family reasons and career changes necessitate moves. In July, 12.4% moved for family reasons and 9.2% bought a home based on a job.
Mid-Atlantic buyers also continue to make discretionary moves, such as to move into a bigger home (13.1%) or to purchase a second home/rental/vacation property (12.9%). Some buyers’ agents also offered that schools were a determining factor. In July, 1.6% wrote in that moving due to the school district was their buyer’s primary motivation for moving. This reason may be seasonal and diminish as the school year gets underway.
What Buyers Can Expect in Today’s Market
In today’s low inventory market, finding the right home is the most daunting task for a buyer. Nearly half of agents said their buyer found this part of the process either very or somewhat difficult.
Buyers still face competition in markets throughout the Mid-Atlantic. Well-priced listings generally garner above list price and receive multiple offers. Nearly half of the homes sold in July had a sale price higher than the original list price. Therefore, buyers must submit competitive offers.
As buyers compete for the same properties, submitting a successful offer becomes their next biggest hurdle after finding the right home. In July, over one in three said this part of homebuying was very or somewhat difficult. First-time buyers, who tend to have lower savings or equity gains from a prior home sale, are more likely than repeat buyers to report that submitting a successful offer was very or somewhat difficult (38.5% versus 31.9%). Three quarters of first-time buyers had to make offers on more than one property and submitted offers on 3.3 homes, on average, before they were successful.
But it isn’t all a walk in the park for repeat buyers. Nearly two in three (65.4%) repeat buyers who bought in July needed to make an offer on more than one home before succeeding. And although repeat buyers tend to face less difficulty submitting a successful offer, finding the right home is just as difficult as it is for first-time buyers, with nearly half of repeat buyers saying it was very (18.2%) or somewhat (31.6%) difficult.
Sellers Need to Ground Expectations
If buyers are competing with other enthusiastic buyers and typically need to offer near or above list price, does that mean what sellers say goes? Not necessarily. Sellers still have the upper hand but must re-orient their expectations to 2023, not 2021 or even 2022.
While low inventory has kept the market competitive, concessions for buyers facing affordability constraints may be necessary to help a transaction cross the finish line. Roughly 47% of listing agents with at least 2 transactions in the past 6 months indicated their sellers either needed to offer concessions or had a deal fall through.

Specifically, about 6% said a contract fell through due to an appraisal and 13% indicated an issue with buyer financing stopped the deal from closing. One in five (21%) of listing agents said that one of their sellers in the past 6 months offered closing cost assistance to their buyer. Nearly 16% provided other concessions like repair credits or home warranties.
Still, most listing agents (70.5%) said concessions were somewhat or very easy. In addition, about three quarters (71.6%) of listing agents indicated that despite the changing housing market, coming to a decision about pricing was somewhat or very easy. But some sellers need to be educated on how their home should be priced and marketed. One listing agent shared, “If a home doesn't show well and is priced too high, it WILL sit longer and sell for less than if priced correctly to start.”
Education is Necessary for Realtors Too
It’s important to re-orient buyer and seller expectations. But it’s also essential to transfer knowledge to real estate agents who are new to the industry. Some comments from survey respondents expressed frustration with new agents who may not be as confident in preparing a deal or negotiating.
Even experienced agents admit that today’s market is uncharted territory. One agent revealed “The market is quite unlike any I've seen in my 21 years in real estate” and another with even more experience acknowledged “I have been in the business for 45+ years and never seen anything like this low inventory and multiple offer situations.”
No matter the number of years, there is always more to learn. Bright MLS offers weekly and monthly housing market reports for the Mid-Atlantic market and metro areas. Bright also offers on-demand and live training and education so that agents and brokers can provide the most value to their clients.
About Bright
Bright is proud to be the source of truth for comprehensive real estate data in the Mid-Atlantic, with market intelligence currently covering six states (Delaware, Maryland, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Virginia, West Virginia) and the District of Columbia. Bright MLS’s innovative tool library—both created and curated—provides services and award-winning support to well over 100k real estate professionals, enabling their delivery on the promise of home to over half a million homebuyers and sellers monthly. In 2022, Bright subscribers facilitated $121B in real estate transactions through the company’s platform.
A total of 643 agents representing recent homebuyers and 718 agents representing recent home sellers responded to Bright MLS’s survey. The survey was conducted between August 7 and August 10, 2023. Full survey results are available here. More research and analysis on the housing market is available from Bright MLS’s Research Team.
Exclusive Market Research & Analysis
For regular updates on the housing market, including weekly insights from Dr. Lisa, please visit BrightMLS.com/Research.
Recent articles
Results from Bright MLS’s survey indicate that 3 out of 4 homes sold for above asking price.