More inventory, lower rates make it easier to be a buyer in 2025.
NEWS
Market Survey: It’s a Whole New Housing Market
For the first time since we began our monthly survey in 2023, agents in the Bright MLS footprint expect seller activity to outpace buyer activity.
There is a noticeable shift underway in the housing market. In Bright MLS’ recent survey of real estate agents, both buyers and sellers are holding back amidst growing uncertainty, and transactions are more likely to be because people need to buy or sell, rather than that they want to buy or sell.
Uncertainty and financial concerns are impacting potential homebuyers
According to real estate agents in the Bright MLS service area, more would-be buyers are deciding to hold off on their home search. In our July survey, nearly three-quarters of survey respondents said they had worked with a buyer who had decided to pause their home search, up less than two-thirds at the same time a year ago.
In the current housing market with inventory rising, it is less about being frustrated at losing out on homes and more about general uncertainty. In the second quarter of 2024, more than 56% of buyers who paused their home search said they did so because they were frustrated by unsuccessful offers. That share dropped to 32.0% in the second quarter of 2025.
Affordability is still a challenge for homebuyers, but in Q2 2025, fewer prospective buyers were sidelined by high home prices and high mortgage rates as the main reason they stopped looking. Agents reported that a growing share of buyers were getting out of the market because of other financial issues (18.1% in Q2 2025 versus 9.2% in Q2 2024) or general uncertainty about the market (32.8% vs. 26.3%).
People are more likely to be buying out of necessity rather than desire
Last year, during the second quarter, 31.4% of people who purchased a home did so simply because they were tired of renting or wanted to become a homeowner, according to agents working in the Bright MLS service area. That share fell to 26.% in the second quarter of 2025. Among buyers in June 2025, only 37.4% of sales were to first-time buyers, the lowest share since we started running this survey in February 2023.
Family and job reasons are more likely to drive home purchases this year. The share who bought for family reasons increased from 15.2% in Q2 2024 to 20.5% in Q2 2025. The share buying for job reasons increased from 10.7% to 12.3%.
In addition, buyers are less likely to be in the market for a second or vacation home. In the second quarter of 2025, 13.2% of purchases in the Bright MLS service area were second, vacation, rental, and investment properties, according to our survey of real estate agents, down from 15.9% a year ago.
The shifting market is influencing prospective home sellers to hold off listing their home
As the housing market softens, an increasing number of sellers are pulling their homes off the market if they can’t get the price they want.
For those sellers who decide not to sell, it is much less likely to be about mortgage rates or not being able to find a home to buy. Rather, a growing share of sellers is de-listing because they are not getting the price they want or for other financial and family reasons.
In Q2 2024, 44.4% of agents said they had a homeowner decide not to sell because they could not find another home to buy. In 2025, that share had dropped to just 21.7%. In 2024, agents said 34.5% of their clients who decided not to sell were motivated by not wanting to give up their mortgage rates. In 2025, only 15.6% of sellers who decided not to sell were influenced by rates.
For would-be sellers in 2025, not being able to get the price they wanted surpassed not wanting to give up mortgage rate. According to surveyed real estate agents, nearly one out of five (19.3%) of their clients who decided not to sell made that decision because they did not get the price they wanted (up from 16.0% of would-be sellers a year ago.)
While the reasons for holding off on selling are changing, sellers are much less likely than buyers to be waiting. According to our survey, during the second quarter of 2025, 35% of agents said they had been working with a seller who decided not to sell their home, which was up only slightly from 34% in Q4 2024.
Shifting means market is moving towards more balance
Each month, we ask real estate agents who are actively working with buyers and sellers to give their forecast of the market over the next three months. The buyer activity and seller activity indices reflect that outlook. When the index is above 50, agents are more optimistic, and when the index is below 50, agents are more pessimistic about future activity.
In our July survey, agents in the Bright MLS footprint said they expect seller activity to outpace buyer activity for the first time since we started collecting this data in April 2023. According to survey respondents, the outlook for buyer activity is declining, while the outlook for seller activity is on the rise. Both indices are right at about 50 in July.
With more seller activity expected and with buyer activity slowing, it is becoming increasingly likely that home prices will continue to soften, with the potential for year-over-year price declines in some local markets. Buyers who are in the market will have more negotiating power than they have had in years, while homeowners who need to sell will need to pay attention to pricing appropriately to attract buyers.
About the survey
Bright MLS conducts monthly surveys of agents who are actively working with buyers and sellers. Each month, a total of about 1,000 agents respond to the survey, including about 500 agents representing buyers and 500 agents representing sellers. Full study results and more research and analysis on the housing market are available from Bright Research.
Exclusive Market Research & Analysis
Get the latest research and studies from Bright at BrightMLS.com/Research.
Recent articles
Uncertainty and compromise kick off the 2025 housing market.