Market Survey: Mid-Atlantic Sees Cooling Market as Spring Closes

Results from Bright MLS’s latest survey reveal that life changes are prompting listing activity.

May 22,  2024

Erica Plemmons

Agents tell us they are seeing cooling market conditions

While sellers have eased back into the market and the outlook for additional seller activity remains higher than last year, Bright MLS subscribers are anticipating a slower housing market over the next three months. According to the latest subscriber survey, the Bright MLS seller activity index was more than seven points above last year’s sentiment level; however, the May 2024 index ticked down compared to April 2024.

Seller Outlook Remains Higher Than Last Year, Buyer Outlook Dips
 

Meanwhile, the Bright MLS buyer activity index has declined both month-over-month and year-over-year. The drop in confidence is likely tied to elevated mortgage rates and continued high prices keeping more buyers on the sidelines. While spring is typically a busy time for the housing market, more agents and brokers in the Bright MLS service area are expecting buyer traffic to slow somewhat in the coming months. In good news, with more new listings coming onto the market, there are more options for those buyers who remain in the market.

Despite Growing Supply, Some Buyers Are Simply Priced Out

Most Bright MLS agents and brokers have worked with potential buyers who are pausing their home search. Nearly three-quarters (73.1%) of buyer agents had a client stop or pause their home search in the past six months, according to the most recent survey. Typically, the largest pain points noted are mortgage rates and high home prices/not finding a home in their price range. But another common factor—frustration with unsuccessful offers or competing with cash—took the second spot and has grown from 53% in February to nearly 62% in May.

Successful buyers are still often required to make offers on multiple properties. Buyers who closed on a home in April made offers on an average of 2.8 homes. Repeat buyers are still in a better position than first-time buyers. Nearly half of repeat buyers (47.7%) purchased with a single offer, compared to just over a third (35.6%) of first-time buyers. Nearly one-fifth (18.7%) of first-time homebuyers in April submitted five or more offers before successfully closing on a home, which is a testament to the strong desire for homeownership.

Number of Offers Similar to 2023; Repeat Buyers Have Upper Hand
 

Is More Inventory on the Way?

In today's shifting market, some sellers are wondering whether now is the right time to list their home. But sellers are less likely to hesitate than buyers, and over time, have adjusted to market conditions and are helping to boost supply. In November 2023, when the question was first introduced, 41.2% of listing agents had a seller pause or stop putting their home on the market in the past six months. As of the most recent survey for May 2024, the percentage has dipped to 32.2%.

Sellers Adjusting to Mortgage Rates, Less Likely to Pause
 

Those who sold in April were generally happy with the offers they got. Over four in five listing agents (83.8%) said their seller was satisfied with the price they received.

The expectation is for new listings to improve compared to last year. While some sellers will wait for better timing, others will list as life continues to happen—marriage, children, health—forcing a change. If mortgage rates finally drop in latter 2024, it will entice more movement on both the list and buy sides.

About Bright

Bright is proud to be the source of truth for comprehensive real estate data in the Mid-Atlantic, with market intelligence currently covering six states (Delaware, Maryland, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Virginia, West Virginia) and the District of Columbia. Bright MLS’s innovative tool library—both created and curated—provides services and award-winning support to well over 100k real estate professionals, enabling their delivery on the promise of home to over half a million homebuyers and sellers monthly. In 2023, Bright subscribers facilitated $104B in real estate transactions through the company’s platform.

A total of 553 agents representing recent homebuyers and 626 agents representing recent home sellers responded to Bright MLS’s survey. The survey was conducted between May 6 and May 14, 2024. Full survey results are available here. More research and analysis on the housing market is available from Bright MLS’s Research Team.

Exclusive Market Research & Analysis

Get the latest research and studies from Bright at BrightMLS.com/Research.

Recent articles

Back to Top