Results from Bright MLS’s survey indicate that buyers in the market are finding easier conditions.
NEWS
Market Survey: You’re Either In or You’re Out
While mortgage rates are not affecting some buyers, results from Bright MLS’s latest survey reveal that rates have led some buyers to drop out of the market.
You’re Either In or You’re Out
Higher mortgage rates have created a divide in the housing market. According to Bright’s latest subscriber survey, nearly three-quarters of October buyers indicated that mortgage rates were not an issue—more than half (51.0%) were going to buy regardless of interest rates and another 20.9% bought with cash.
However, those who haven’t completed a successful transaction have a different vantage point. More than three-quarters of buyer agents (78.1%) with at least two clients in the past six months indicated that at least one of their potential buyers decided to stop or pause their search. When asked the reason, nearly three in five (58.4%) cited “rates” as a reason why their buyer(s) moved to the sidelines.
The impact of higher rates on buyers is understandable. At today’s rates, a buyer would need an income of $125,000 to qualify for a loan to buy the median-priced home in the Bright MLS service area.
Other agents added that some of their buyers were frustrated when their offers weren’t accepted. After so many “no’s,” they needed a time out. Low inventory has also caused some buyers to sit out of the market. Some simply can’t find a home to buy; others can’t find a home worth the move or the higher mortgage rates.
Still in the Market? Get Ready to Compete
Tight inventory means buyers still face competition. Multiple offers continue to be the norm throughout the Bright MLS service area, especially for attractively located and well-priced properties. However, market conditions are somewhat easier than they were a few months ago. In October, 56.4% of buyers had to make offers on multiple homes before they were successful. But back in the summer, nearly 70% of buyers were making multiple offers in order to buy a home.
First-time buyers are more likely than repeat buyers to have to make multiple offers. Yet conditions have been easing for both groups since the summer. In July, 74.8% of first-time buyers had made offers on multiple homes. In October, that share had fallen to 63.6%. By comparison, 65.4% of July repeat buyers and just over half (51.2%) of October repeat buyers were forced to make offers on multiple properties before they were ultimately successful.
That doesn’t mean there aren’t still challenges. Buyers who find success have similar frustrations to those who paused or stopped their home search. Finding the right home continued to be the toughest part of the buying process in October, with 39.8% of agents saying it was somewhat or very difficult for their buyers. The next biggest hurdle was submitting a successful offer, similar to previous months.
First-Time Buyers Are Hanging in There
First-time buyers face more obstacles, but they are still active in the market this fall. In October, 40.8% of buying agents indicated the individual(s) who purchased were first-time buyers. When the survey launched, a similar percentage of February buyers (41.4%) were first-time buyers. The percentage increased over the following months before dipping to lows around 38% in August and September.
First-time buyers do not typically have the cash or built-up home equity to put toward a purchase, but they do have the motivation. First-time buyers are more likely than repeat buyers to use savings (76.7% vs. 56.1%) or use government programs (11.9% vs. 2.3%) for a down payment. But their down payment tends to be lower, with nearly three-quarters of first-time buyers (72.4%) putting down less than 20%.
Rates Edging Down From 8% Won’t Motivate Many Sellers
Successful sellers also tend to dismiss mortgage rates when deciding to list. About nine out of 10 (88.8%) October sellers said they were going to sell regardless of interest rates. That share has remained relatively constant since the survey began in February 2023.
Still, there’s another group of potential sellers who aren’t ready to take the plunge. Of listing agents who represented at least two clients in the past six months, two in five (41.3%) said that at least one of their sellers decided not to sell and “rates” influenced 20.4% of sellers who decided not to sell.
Other homeowners were not selling because they could not find their next home and struggled with the lack of inventory (29.4%). Some couldn’t find a home on the market to suit their needs while others who weighed their current home (both features and payment) were unwilling to make a swap.
Some sellers still have not reset their expectations to reflect the current market. Agents responded that some of their sellers backed away after realizing they couldn’t get the high price they wanted for their home. The Mid-Atlantic definitely needs more inventory, and the good news is that some sellers are simply waiting for spring. When those sellers list, both patient and pausing buyers will be ready to explore additional options.
About Bright
Bright is proud to be the source of truth for comprehensive real estate data in the Mid-Atlantic, with market intelligence currently covering six states (Delaware, Maryland, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Virginia, West Virginia) and the District of Columbia. Bright MLS’s innovative tool library—both created and curated—provides services and award-winning support to well over 100k real estate professionals, enabling their delivery on the promise of home to over half a million homebuyers and sellers monthly. In 2022, Bright subscribers facilitated $121B in real estate transactions through the company’s platform.
A total of 564 agents representing recent homebuyers and 687 agents representing recent home sellers responded to Bright MLS’s survey. The survey was conducted between November 6 and November 13, 2023. Full survey results are available here. More research and analysis on the housing market is available from Bright MLS’s Research Team.
Exclusive Market Research & Analysis
For regular updates on the housing market, including weekly insights from Dr. Lisa, please visit BrightMLS.com/Research.
Recent articles
Results from Bright MLS’s survey indicate that agents and brokers are anticipating weaker demand this fall but are more optimistic about 2024.