Results from Bright MLS’s survey indicate that education and cooperation are essential for a smooth transaction process.
NEWS
Market Survey: Hibernation Ahead for Mid-Atlantic
Results from Bright MLS’s survey indicate that agents and brokers are anticipating weaker demand this fall but are more optimistic about 2024.
Who Moved This Summer?
Over the summer (June through August), about a quarter (24.4%) of buyers moving into or within the Bright MLS footprint moved from one state to another, either moving cross-country or simply hopping the state line, according to a recent survey of Bright MLS subscribers. In fact, nearly half (46.3%) of agents who had a summer buyer moving from a different state shared that the buyer originated from another state in the Mid-Atlantic. The top three states when the buyer moved from a different state are New Jersey, Maryland, and Virginia.
Other buyers are relocating from farther away. The top state outside of the Mid-Atlantic is New York, with many of those buyers headed to New Jersey, Pennsylvania, and Maryland. Following New York are some farther-out states: Florida, California, North Carolina, and Texas.
Yet the majority of people move locally. In the Mid-Atlantic, nearly half (47.2%) of summer buyers (June through August) moved within the same county. And roughly a quarter (25.9%) switched counties within the same state.
Local and out-of-town buyers will still be purchasing in the fall, but the Mid-Atlantic real estate market is starting its seasonal shift. Additionally, mortgage rates surpassing 7% have curtailed demand and moved some buyers to the sidelines.
Weakening Demand for the Rest of 2023
No matter where buyers come from, agents and brokers are planning for lower activity. In September, the number of survey respondents expecting high to very high buyer activity over the next three months was 25.7%, which is significantly lower than the share in April (50.5%) who anticipated high to very high activity approaching the summer months. Part of this change is simply because market demand traditionally slows down during the fall and winter. But there are other factors agents and brokers are seeing that point to weaker demand this fall.
“It is difficult to see how the market builds positive momentum the rest of 2023, given seasonality, student loans, rates, and the news cycle,” one agent remarked.
Further, the outlook for seller activity has also moderated. Mortgage rates impact not only buyers but sellers who may want to upsize or downsize. Compared to April, when 50.7% of respondents predicted low to very low activity three months out, the percentage increased to 65.0% among agents and brokers responding to September’s survey.
Buyers, Particularly First-Time Buyers, Must Be Prepared
Inventory will be a significant hurdle for fall buyers. Homebuyers who closed on a house in August found the most challenging part of the homebuying process to be finding the right home, followed by submitting a successful offer, consistent with June and July. Both first-time and repeat buyers struggled similarly in their search for the right home. However, first-time homebuyers had more difficulty submitting a successful offer.
Repeat buyers may have easier success due to their financial situation and that they are typically able to put extra money into a down payment. More than 3 in 5 repeat buyers (61.3%) put at least 20% down, with 13.8% able to pay cash for 100% of the home purchase. For first-time buyers, 25.7% had exactly a 20% down payment and only 12.0% put down more than that.
According to the September survey, the majority of first-time buyers used savings for all or part of the down payment (72.1%). About 22.1% of respondents said their first-time buyer received a gift from family or friends to use for the down payment compared to 5.9% of repeat buyers. First-time homebuyers can also benefit from government programs (7.1%) to help with the down payment.
Listings Continue From Sellers Who Need to Move
According to agents who worked with a seller in August, the most likely reason a seller listed their home was due to family reasons such as marriage, divorce, or moving closer to relatives. Estate sales have also been an important source of listings in the Mid-Atlantic.
Many are staying put, attached to their ultra-low mortgage rates or worried about finding another home that is better than their current one. Some sellers are still in the market to move to a home that is a better fit, with 11.0% listing because they wanted a bigger home and 11.0% because they wanted a smaller home. Another 11.0% of agents said their seller was listing a vacation home, rental, or investment property.
Buyers continue to outpace sellers in the existing home market. One buyer agent commented, “My clients got tired of search[ing] resale and not finding what they wanted.” Then the agent connected the buyer to an alternative—new construction. Buyers in areas with this option may have less heartache. “This was a new build with a 30-day close - this was much easier for them.”
Inventory may rise as elevated mortgage rates eat into demand. Still, the existing home market tightness is unlikely to change in the near term.
Buyers, Agents and Brokers Welcome 2024 With Open Arms
With weakened demand and low supply, agents and brokers aren’t as optimistic about the remainder of 2023. On the other hand, many are looking forward to a better 2024. Some predict the spring will be “robust” and “strong.”
The 7%+ rates have made some buyers say enough is enough. One agent remarked, “Buyers can’t find the inventory they need/want and are also trying to hold off on buying hoping the rates will go down in 2024.”
While some buyers are taking a wait-and-see mentality, others will persist in the fall. August buyers typically submitted 3.2 offers to be successful, which means that buyers are still facing stiff competition in the market. As the fall buying season kicks off, we’ll see if homebuyers who purchase during this slower time face less heat than their summer peers or if low inventory keeps the competition just as intense.
About Bright
Bright is proud to be the source of truth for comprehensive real estate data in the Mid-Atlantic, with market intelligence currently covering six states (Delaware, Maryland, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Virginia, West Virginia) and the District of Columbia. Bright MLS’s innovative tool library—both created and curated—provides services and award-winning support to well over 100k real estate professionals, enabling their delivery on the promise of home to over half a million homebuyers and sellers monthly. In 2022, Bright subscribers facilitated $121B in real estate transactions through the company’s platform.
A total of 662 agents representing recent homebuyers and 779 agents representing recent home sellers responded to Bright MLS’s survey. The survey was conducted between September 7 and September 12, 2023. Full survey results are available here. More research and analysis on the housing market is available from Bright MLS’s Research Team.
Exclusive Market Research & Analysis
For regular updates on the housing market, including weekly insights from Dr. Lisa, please visit BrightMLS.com/Research.
Recent articles
Lack of Repeat Buyers Opens Window for First-Time Home Shoppers.